The Upright vs The Gentleman
The primary distinction between these two sampled upright pianos lies in their core recording methodology and overall sample depth. The Upright by Audio Brewers emphasizes an Ambisonics recording approach, offering extensive control over listener perspective, while The Gentleman by Native Instruments focuses on capturing the authentic character of a specific vintage instrument with detailed noise modeling.
The Upright features an extensive 17,800 samples across 14 velocity layers within a 16.3 GB library, prioritizing a clean, atmospheric character suited for immersive productions. In contrast, The Gentleman, based on a 1908 Bechstein Model A, utilizes 2,300 samples with 16 velocity layers in a 13 GB library, specifically detailing release and pedal noises to replicate an antique instrument's warmth and intimacy.
Choose The Upright if spatial audio control and an immersive, natural soundstage are paramount for applications like VR or surround mixes. Choose The Gentleman if a historically accurate, warm, and intimate upright sound with detailed mechanical nuances from a specific vintage piano is desired for traditional recording, pop, or jazz.
Products Compared
Insights from Real-World Use
The Upright
- Impressive stereo sound, 14 velocity layers make it feel like a real piano with great tone and feel.
- Praises The Upright's realistic tuning, which emulates a real piano's imperfect intonation.
- An impressive piano library with great sound, realistic feel from velocity layers, and extensive sound design possibilities.
- The Upright has immaculate samples, is very playable, and great as a felt and normal piano, though slightly less dynamic than preferred. A great instrument.
- High-quality samples allow for versatile sound exploration.
The Gentleman
- Detailed sampling of key signs, quick pedals, and mechanical noise captures authentic character.
- Highly adjustable dynamic range makes it great for various genres.
- The Gentleman is versatile, excellent for classical, film scores, and sounds great when manipulated.
- All three pianos sound great but have vastly different characteristics.
- Native Instruments The Gentleman Loopcloud Melodics. 5 ... The keyboard itself is fabulous, and comes with an astounding array of music software. Review.