Alicia's Electric Keys vs Noire

The most fundamental difference between Noire and Alicia's Electric Keys lies in their instrument type and sonic character. Noire is a sampled acoustic grand piano, specifically a Yamaha CFX, designed for a warm, intimate, and often atmospheric sound, whereas Alicia's Electric Keys emulates an electric grand piano, the Yamaha CP-70, known for its distinct character, often employed in pop and modern songwriting.

Noire, with its two variants (Pure and Felt), offers a range from cinematic to dark and intimate acoustic textures, enhanced by a unique 'Particles Engine' for sonic effects, and meticulously recorded in Nils Frahm’s studio. In contrast, Alicia's Electric Keys focuses on replicating a specific artist’s signature sound, featuring custom-made effect chains and modeling Alicia Keys’ personal CP-70, providing a sound integral to pop and contemporary music.

Choose Noire if you seek a versatile, high-fidelity acoustic grand piano with options for atmospheric sound design and a wide dynamic range, suitable for film scoring and classical compositions. Choose Alicia's Electric Keys if your productions require the iconic, processed electric grand piano sound, particularly for pop, R&B, or songwriting where a distinct, modern character is desired.

Products Compared

Insights from Real-World Use

Alicia's Electric Keys

  • Thinks Alicia’s Electric Keys is excellent for mellow CP70 sound and natural touch.
  • Says the 82 presets sound pretty good and outnumber Alicia's Keys.
  • Acknowledges steep price but argues presets and deep controls deliver professional, sound-design value.
  • Praises UI meter words that illuminate and flicker with playing intensity.
  • Says it sits well in dense mixes without overpowering like some grand pianos.

Noire

  • I've owned Noire from day one, and I still play it almost every day.. While it's only a sampled version, it's the best a mere mortal like myself will even get since a Yamaha CFX 9' grand piano is fina
  • 45 years playing the piano here, and this is the most amazing piano VST ever made!
  • Noire excels at unique, atmospheric soundscapes for writing and sound design.
  • This plugin is loved for its versatility, tone quality, and great value.
  • Noire isn't a primary detailed acoustic replacement, yet it still offers a nice sound.

Explore PianoVST