Pianoteq 9 vs Ivory 3 LE Uprights

Pianoteq 9 and Ivory 3 LE Uprights differ fundamentally in their sound generation technology and instrument scope. Pianoteq 9 exclusively uses physical modeling to synthesize piano sounds, offering a multi-instrument collection with numerous distinct grand piano models and one upright, emphasizing an experimental character. In contrast, Ivory 3 LE Uprights employs a hybrid engine, combining sampling with modeling, and focuses specifically on two upright pianos—a modern Yamaha U5 and a vintage 1914 Hume—captured with a substantial 12 GB library.

The technical approaches yield distinct sonic characteristics and flexibility. Pianoteq's modeling engine allows for extensive real-time parameter adjustments and a clean, bright sound suitable for complex productions. Ivory 3 LE Uprights, leveraging its hybrid engine and sampled foundation, delivers a natural and balanced tone, highlighting the specific character of its source uprights through detailed stereo recordings and an integrated mixing desk.

Choose Pianoteq 9 if you require a versatile collection of physically modeled grand and upright pianos with deep customization, favoring a brighter, more experimental sound for diverse musical applications like film scoring or classical. Opt for Ivory 3 LE Uprights if your priority is a warm, natural, and character-rich upright piano sound derived from high-quality samples, specifically for genres like pop and songwriting where the unique timbre of an upright is desired.

Products Compared

Insights from Real-World Use

Pianoteq 9

  • Says Pianoteq’s realism is next-level, surpassing Logic’s piano and many real recordings.
  • Calls Pianoteq his go-to piano, expressing strong overall endorsement and trust.
  • I have played around with Pianoteq for some time, actually since version 1. ... Back in the early versions it had a thin very sterile, synthetic sound. But, I knew they were on to the right idea. ...
  • Not ideal for instant use, but great if you want deep customization.
  • The Hamburg Steinway Blues with the unisons detuned to taste sounds very realistic. Also helps to eq to taste, always seems to need more mids around four to five kh. I usually use a hundred hz bass ro

Ivory 3 LE Uprights

  • Highlighting the character and 'heart' of the vintage Ivory 3 LE Uprights sound.
  • The Modern U is very nice. The difference here is that the Ivory 3 LE uprights have a single stereo mic pair. Ivory3 uses their new engine which gives you so much under the hood control of the sound.
  • Appreciating the unique 'something' in the 'Smoky' preset.
  • Appreciating the lively and responsive velocity layers of Ivory 3 LE Uprights.
  • CraigNZ I'm looking forward to your update review of this Ivory upright... I got the full set of four Synthogy uprights for something like $35 from...

Explore PianoVST