Shearwater Piano vs My Piano

The central distinction between Shearwater Piano and My Piano lies in their intended sonic aesthetics and available features, despite both being sampled upright pianos. Shearwater emphasizes a characterful, intimate, and potentially lo-fi sound, whereas My Piano aims for a natural, balanced tone with detailed physical modeling.

My Piano offers specific features like 6 velocity layers, release samples, internal resonances, sympathetic and pedal resonance, and even "occasional crackles" to enhance realism. Shearwater, while also intimate, offers a unique "paper mode" achieved by recording with masking tape over the strings, suggesting a more specialized and experimental tonal option beyond standard piano articulation.

Choose Shearwater Piano if a distinct, character-rich, or experimental upright sound, particularly the "paper mode," is desired for ambient or film scoring contexts, especially given its budget pricing. Choose My Piano if a highly detailed and naturally balanced upright piano with extensive physical modeling and realistic performance nuances is preferred, especially for classical, jazz, or general recording, noting its free accessibility.

Products Compared

Insights from Real-World Use