The Giant vs Montclarion Hall Grand Piano

The fundamental distinction between The Giant and Montclarion Hall Grand Piano lies in their source instruments and sonic applications. The Giant is based on a unique, dramatically sized upright piano, the Klavins Model 370i, designed for a powerful and dramatic sound. In contrast, Montclarion Hall Grand Piano samples a vintage 1926 Steinway parlor grand, focusing on a more classic grand piano tone recorded in a distinctive acoustic space.

Sonically, The Giant offers a bright, intimate, and modern character with a wide dynamic range, including a notable bass and a crisp attack that can emulate a harpsichord. It also features a second instrument variant with special piano sounds and effects. Montclarion Hall Grand Piano emphasizes a bright, balanced, and natural grand piano sound with lush acoustic reflections from its chapel recording environment. Its library notably includes extensive 'prepared piano' and creative FX articulations, such as percussive sounds and string manipulations, moving beyond a standard grand piano.

Choose The Giant if you seek a unique, powerful, and dramatic upright piano sound for modern, intimate, or film scoring contexts, especially benefiting from its distinct tonal character and additional sound design variant. Opt for Montclarion Hall Grand Piano if you require a classic, balanced Steinway grand piano sound with natural spaciousness and desire extensive experimental and prepared piano articulations for sound design and diverse musical genres.

Products Compared

Insights from Real-World Use

The Giant

  • The Giant is a great-sounding instrument that I really like, especially in XXL mode.
  • Recommends The Giant for scoring movies due to its presets and deep tweakability, validating its price.
  • The Giant is a flexible library with excellent mixing tools, suitable for multiple musical styles.
  • The Giant's controls make it versatile for classical and electronic music, a key reason for the user's preference.
  • it is my go-to for piano. The sound is top notch.

Montclarion Hall Grand Piano

  • Worth the price, but not suited as a main piano.
  • The room and hall contribute significantly to the Montclarion Hall Grand Piano's sound.
  • This is a steal for only 50 bucks imo, ive heard more expensive piano libraries that doesnt sound as good
  • Dislikes the default negative gain setting.
  • Least favorite of the four, but notes cool custom presets.

Explore PianoVST