Ivory 3 German D vs Hammersmith Pro
Ivory 3 German D and Hammersmith Pro both feature sampled Steinway Model D grand pianos aimed at premium production, but they diverge significantly in their core technology and recording approach. Ivory 3 utilizes a unique hybrid RGB Engine, which aims to combine the responsiveness of modeling with the realism of sampling, offering a dynamic and expressive playing experience. In contrast, Hammersmith Pro relies solely on a traditional sample-based engine, meticulously captured with an exceptionally high number of 21 velocity layers per note.
Beyond their engine types, their recording methodologies present key differences. Ivory 3 captured an "exceptional German Steinway D Concert Grand" with four mic positions, highlighting its classic Steinway tone and balanced sound. Hammersmith Pro, however, was recorded at British Grove Studios using a Steinway Model D with a rare retro-fitted MIDI self-play system, allowing for precise capture across six mic positions and over 30,000 samples, including separate recordings for sustain pedal up and down.
Choose Ivory 3 German D if you prioritize a groundbreaking hybrid engine that promises fluid expressiveness akin to modeling while retaining sample realism. Choose Hammersmith Pro if you require an extremely detailed and deep-sampled instrument, emphasizing the extensive velocity layers and precise recording environment for maximum sonic fidelity.
Products Compared
Insights from Real-World Use
Ivory 3 German D
- Ivory 3 German D excels in dynamic range, allowing for unrestricted fortissimo, which is its strong suit.
- The spectral modeling and sampling, especially the tamber shift, make Ivory 3 German D sound nice and covered.
- Ivory 3 German D's modeling makes playing more musical and expressive.
- Ivory 3's awesome effects are amazing, offering quality usually found elsewhere.
- The dynamic range of Ivory 3 German D, from true fortissimo to very soft, is highly appreciated.
Hammersmith Pro
- The 21 velocity layers and sound capture are excellent, indicating a well-crafted library.
- The piano offers nice responsiveness, dynamic range, and playability due to 21 velocity layers.
- The piano has a nice sparkle and sounds good even without effects.
- I have downloaded the free version and am very impressed. I have added the full version to my "wish list of purchases". It is currently sitting right next to Pianoteq V7. I try to keep my piano librar
- Overload on my PC. Especially when playing this instruments inside Daw while we recording the screen.