Concert Grand vs Ivory 3 American Concert D
The fundamental distinction between Concert Grand by Production Voices and Ivory 3 American Concert D by Synthogy lies in their core sound generation philosophy and the detailed depth of their sample sets. Production Voices employs a purely sample-based engine, prioritizing an exceptionally large number of samples and velocity layers, while Synthogy utilizes a hybrid engine that blends sampling with modeling for its unique "Continuous Velocity" feature.
Concert Grand offers up to 23 velocity layers for pedal-up samples and 16 for release samples, alongside an unparalleled library size of 1157 GB uncompressed, captured through nine microphone positions. In contrast, Ivory 3 American Concert D, while also based on a Steinway Model D, features a more compact 38 GB library with four microphone positions, distinguishing itself with its Real-time Gradient Blending (RGB) engine that delivers "Continuous Velocity" for seamless timbre transitions.
Choose Concert Grand if your priority is maximal sample depth, granular control over microphone perspectives, and a vast uncompressed sample library for ultimate realism. Opt for Ivory 3 American Concert D if you seek the organic playability and expressive nuances offered by its hybrid engine’s continuous velocity, coupled with a more streamlined library size and a distinct vintage Steinway character.
Products Compared
Insights from Real-World Use
Concert Grand
- The pre-attack noise was really noisy. I had the samples but decided to hold off given the size of the library. Maybe I'll add them back in in a future update...
- My ideal setup for Concert Grand is basically Balanced Robust, but without the room mics.
- While Noire does sound good, I have one that's so much better: Production Voices 300 Grand... concert-grand-virtual-piano/ · Psychotic_Member69. • 2y ago. Fl
Ivory 3 American Concert D
- Each piano has a unique tone signature, suitable for different songs.
- I listened to the review twice and what my uneducated ears heard was Ivory 3 sounding a bit more airy with ambiance baked in. The piano seems a bit more open.
- It sounds slightly hollow in the mid highs. It’s missing some weight that makes it sound really static.
- American D is brighter (halfway to a Yamaha), while German one is darker.
- I listened to the review twice and what my uneducated ears heard was Ivory 3 sounding a bit more airy with ambiance baked in. The piano seems a bit more open.